Green Bay-Area Neighborhood Fence Dispute Escalates as Homeowners Face New Lawsuit Over $200,000 Settlement
A years-long backyard fence dispute in a Wisconsin neighborhood has turned into another legal battle, with homeowners now facing lawsuits over unpaid settlement costs. What began as a family’s request to build a fence for children with disabilities eventually resulted in a $200,000 settlement, leaving neighborhood residents facing individual bills of approximately $1,350.
The dispute centers on the Nazcr Trac neighborhood in De Pere, near Green Bay, where the homeowners’ association’s decision to enforce a no-fence rule triggered litigation and financial consequences for residents.
How the Fence Dispute Started
Michael and Lisa Newman, who have five children, wanted to install a backyard fence so their children could safely play outdoors. After some of their children were diagnosed with autism, the family requested an accommodation from the Nazcr Trac Property Owners Association (NTPOA), which had a subdivision rule prohibiting fences.
The family cited concerns that two children had a significant risk of elopement, meaning they could potentially wander away unsafely. Their accommodation requests, submitted in July 2019 and again in December 2020, reportedly went unanswered.
In August 2021, the Newmans filed a federal lawsuit alleging disability discrimination under the Fair Housing Amendments Act.
Key Details of the Wisconsin Neighborhood Dispute
| Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Location | Nazcr Trac, De Pere, Wisconsin |
| Family involved | Michael and Lisa Newman and their five children |
| Original dispute | Backyard fence and no-fence neighborhood rule |
| Initial request | July 2019 |
| Second request | December 2020 |
| Lawsuit filed | August 2021 |
| Settlement amount | $200,000 |
| Reported household charge | Approximately $1,350 |
| New lawsuit | Filed against association and homeowners over unpaid amounts |
Court Decision and $200,000 Settlement
In May 2022, a judge issued a preliminary injunction preventing the association from enforcing its no-fence rule against the family. The Newmans were then able to build their fence.
A settlement reached in August 2024 reportedly required the association to pay the family $200,000. The cost was passed on to neighborhood households, with residents reportedly facing bills of $1,350 each.
Some residents said they were frustrated because they had not been aware of the legal dispute before receiving the payment demand.
One resident told WGBA:
“A large amount of the members would have said, ‘Absolutely, let the family do what they need to do to take care of their family.'”
Lisa Newman also expressed regret over the financial impact on neighbors, saying:
“It’s just a really unfortunate situation, I think, for everybody involved.”
Why Homeowners Are Facing Another Lawsuit
The dispute returned in September when the Newmans filed another lawsuit against the association and homeowners who allegedly had not paid their share of the settlement.
According to their attorney, Victoria Davis Dávila, 69 homeowners had settled following the earlier lawsuit, while 33 residents were named in the new filing.
Key developments include:
- The original settlement reportedly totaled $200,000.
- Individual households were assessed approximately $1,350.
- Some homeowners allegedly still have outstanding payments.
- The new filing names the association and 33 residents.
- The association’s answer and affirmative defense were filed on November 16, but details were not publicly available in the report.
Davis Dávila told WGBA:
“There’s an outstanding judgment. You had the opportunity to pay. You chose not to pay it.”
What Happens Next?
The latest lawsuit could extend the neighborhood’s legal conflict further, as homeowners who believed the settlement issue was resolved are now facing renewed legal pressure. The association’s response and the court’s next decisions could determine how the outstanding settlement amount is handled.
Stay Updated with LifeScienceReport.com
For more trending news, neighborhood disputes, legal developments and important stories from across the country, visit LifeScienceReport.com and stay informed about the latest developments.