California Mother and Daughter Arrested in 2022 Murder After Severed Head Found in Trash Bag

California Mother and Daughter Arrested in 2022 Murder After Severed Head Found in Trash Bag

California authorities have arrested a mother and daughter in connection with the killing of a 73-year-old man whose severed head was discovered in a trash bag in 2022. Investigators say the victim, Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., had never been reported missing, and his family allegedly continued creating the impression that he was still alive for years.

How Investigators Identified the Victim

On September 28, 2022, a dog walker discovered a trash bag containing a human head in the Todd Valley area of Foresthill, California, near the time the Mosquito wildfire was burning in the region.

Investigators initially struggled to identify the victim because of the condition of the remains. An autopsy, forensic examination and artist’s rendering failed to produce a match. His DNA was also entered into the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS), but no matching record was found.

In January 2024, detectives submitted the DNA for forensic genetic genealogy testing. The results helped investigators identify possible relatives, eventually leading authorities to Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr.

Key Details of the Case

Case DetailInformation
VictimPaul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr.
Victim’s Age73
DaughterMary Fitzmaurice, 45
WifeGeorgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, 75
Discovery DateSeptember 28, 2022
Discovery LocationTodd Valley, Foresthill, California
Daughter’s ChargeMurder
Mother’s ChargeAccessory
Identification MethodForensic genetic genealogy

Mother and Daughter Arrested

The Placer County Sheriff’s Office said investigators believe Mary Fitzmaurice was responsible for her father’s death at the family’s Citrus Heights residence. Authorities also allege that the mother and daughter conspired to dispose of his remains.

The sheriff’s office reported that both women were arrested on November 17, 2026. Mary was booked on a murder charge, while her mother, Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, was booked on an accessory charge.

Allegations About Social Security and Pension Payments

Investigators said the women allegedly continued receiving the man’s Social Security benefits and California public pension payments after his death.

According to Sheriff Wayne Woo, relatives were reportedly told that Paul had become reclusive and would disappear for days at a time.

Authorities said the explanations helped maintain the appearance that he was still alive.

What Authorities Have Not Revealed

Investigators have not publicly disclosed a possible motive for the killing. Authorities also have not located the rest of the victim’s remains. Sheriff Woo said a search of the family’s residence did not uncover additional remains.

The investigation represents a significant breakthrough in a case that remained unidentified for more than four years.

Stay Updated with LifeScienceReport.com

For more breaking news, crime stories, major investigations and important developments across the United States, visit LifeScienceReport.com. Stay informed with the latest stories and updates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top